The Frontier Design Benchmark is live.

Read on XLinkedIn

Carafe website

15 Outputs138 Votes
Golden

Model outputs

15 models + golden

    How the models rank on this task

    Leaderboard
    Contra LabsFrontier Design Benchmark
    50% · even
    1. Human golden
    2. Kimi K3.1 Pro
    3. GPT-6 Astra
    4. GPT-6.1 Sol
    5. Claude Opus 5.5
    6. Claude Sonnet 5.5
    7. Qwen3.8 Max
    8. Claude Fable 5.2
    9. Kimi K3
    10. Gemini 4 Carbon
    11. GLM-5.3 Prime
    12. Muse Spark 1.3
    13. DeepSeek V4 Pro
    14. Gemini 4 Argon
    15. Grok 4.7
    16. Muse Wonder

    Quality report

    How we score
    Rubric score68/100
    AI grade35%
    AI slop61/100
    D1.1 Focal point & importance-to-prominence mapping: PassD1.2 Prominence of primary actions & controls: PassD1.3 Competing elements & distraction: PassD4.1 Layout structure & grid: PassD4.2 Alignment & placement: PassD4.3 Spacing & padding: MajorD4.4 Density & white space: PassD4.5 Scale & proportion of elements: PassD4.6 Section order & narrative flow: PassD5.2 Grouping & separation: PassStructureStructureD2.3 Typeface choice & pairing: MinorD2.4 Type scale & hierarchy: PassD2.5 Typesetting detail: PassD3.1 Palette choice & harmony: PassD3.2 Colour discipline & meaning: PassD6.1 Consistency of the visual system (incl. monotony vs variety): PassD6.3 Restraint & purposefulness of elements: MajorD6.4 Shadows, textures & decorative effects: MinorD6.5 Rendering integrity (overlap, clipping, cropping): MinorD6.6 Craft finish & refinement: MinorD7.1 Relevance & integration of imagery: PassD7.2 Quality & craft of images, illustrations & graphics: PassD7.3 Icon clarity & recognisability: PassD7.4 Charts, tables & data display: PassD7.5 Logo & mark craft: PassD10.1 Fit to brand, product, audience & context: PassVisual craftVisual craftD8.1 Presence & placement of expected controls: PassD8.2 Interactive cues & state clarity: PassD9.1 Copy quality, tone & correctness: PassD9.2 Message clarity, ease of understanding & information sufficiency: PassD9.3 Text volume & concision: PassD9.4 Content credibility & factual coherence: PassD11.1 Colour contrast (text, icons & key elements): PassD11.2 Readable text size: MajorD11.3 Touch target size & spacing: MajorContent & useContent & use
    68Rubric score
    35 aspects27 pass4 minor4 major

    Prompt

    We're Carafe, a hospitality design studio known for our restaurant and culinary projects. The people visiting our site are restaurateurs and hospitality groups looking for a studio, plus press and people who might want to work with us. We want a portfolio site that celebrates the work and shows how considered our practice is. Think strong typography, lots of white space and image-led editorial layouts, something elevated, modern and timeless. Please use our logo as the starting point.

    We need these pages: Homepage; a Works overview and individual Works pages; a News overview with News Individual, Publications & Monograph, and Lectures & Awards; About, with Studio, Team and Philosophy; Careers; Contact; and Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy. The editorial layouts need careful handling on smaller screens, with subtle motion where it helps, and it should be accessible.

    Stack

    Build it with React, using Vite (TypeScript or JavaScript).

    The rest of the brief isn’t published. Contact us to learn more

    Input files

    7 files came with the brief. They aren’t published. Contact us to learn more

      Metadata

      Kind of work
      A portfolio for a culinary and hospitality studio
      Category
      Website
      Deliverable
      A working website · 390, 768 and 1440 px
      Brief
      Contra’s marketplace, the client renamed
      Client
      Carafe
      Golden
      Carafe, hospitality design studio in Bangkok. Made by a designer
      Evaluation
      138 counted blind votes by 17 reviewers
      Sign inGet in touch